笔者索性以Leibniz Prize为关键字继续古狗,查看历来获得Leibniz奖科学
家名单,看看杨玉良提供的两种版本哪个讲的是真话.果然在维基百科(Wikipedia,
the free encyclopedia)中有Leibniz奖自1985年以来历届获奖名单,其中1987年
9项13人,1988年12项,15人,姓名和获奖者单位如下:
1987 (9项, 13人): 1. Gerhard Abstreiter (Technical University of
Munich); 2. Knut Borchardt (Ludwig Maximilians University of Munich);3.
Nils Claussen (Technical University of Hamburg-Harburg);4. Bernd Giese
(Darmstadt University of Technology);5. Wolfgang A. Herrmann and
Hubert Schmidbaur (Technical University of Munich);6. Günter Hotz,
Kurt Mehlhorn and Wolfgang Paul (Saarland University);7. Erwin Neher
and Bert Sakmann (, G?ttingen);8. Friedrich A. Seifert (University of
Bayreuth),Rudolf K. Thauer (Philipps University of Marburg);9.
Hans-Peter Zenner (University of Würzburg)
1988 (12项,15人): 1. Karl Joachim Ebeling (Technische Universit?t
Braunschweig);2. Lothar Gall (Johann Wolfgang Goethe University
Frankfurt am Main);3. Günter Harder (University of Bonn);4. Walter
Haug and Burghart Wachinger (Eberhard Karls University of Tübingen); 5.
Werner Hildenbrand (University of Bonn); 6. Ingo Müller (Technische
Universit?t Berlin);7. Herbert W. Roesky and George Michael Sheldrick
- (Georg August University of G?ttingen);8. Wolfram Saenger and Volker
Erdmann (Free University of Berlin);9. Günther Schütz (German Cancer
Research Center,Heidelberg);10. Hans Wolfgang Spiess (Max Planck
Institute for Polymer Research, Mainz);11. Karl Otto Stetter
(University of Regensburg); 12. Thomas Weiland (DESY (German electron
synchrotron), Hamburg).
a）Type of Prize：The largest award in German research 此系德国最
大研究奖项。
b）Number and Value of Awards：Up to ten prizes are awarded
annually with a maximum of �2.5 million per award。每年授予至多十人
（注：有些年份略多，11人），每位获奖人至多250万欧元科研基金（注：给研
究组的科研经费。从这点看很明显这个奖项不大可能颁给博士后个人）。
c）需要很复杂的提名和选拔程序，而且个人自己不能提名本人（It is not
possible to nominate yourself.）。试想一个刚到德国工作一两年的中国博士
后，工作才刚刚起步，有没有可能得到强有力的提名？如果有，那么该是怎样的
重大科研进展？退一万步说，假如有了如此的成果，不是比得了这个奖更值得荣
耀？那还不变本加厉的吹嘘？
a）Dynamic Magic-angle Spinning NMR-spectroscopy-exchange-induce
side-band.
Y. Yang, M. Schuster, B. Blumich, H. W. Spiess, Chem. Phys. Lett.,
139 (3-4), 239-243 (1987)
b) 2D Magic Angle Spinning NMR Spectroscopy Correlation between
Molecular Order and Dynamics.
Y. Yang, A. Hagemeyer, H. W. Spiess, Chem. Phys. Lett., 150 (1-2),
1-5 (1988)
c) An Order-Exchange Correlated 2D NMR Study of Slow Molecular
Motion in Highly Oriented Crystalline Poly (oxymethylene).
Y. Yang, A. Hagemeyer, H. W. Spiess, Macromolecules, 22, 1004 (1989)
d) Annealing Effect on Orientation in Dynamically Sheared Diblock
Copolymers.
Y. Zhang, U. Wiesner, Y. Yang, T. Pakula, and H. W. Spiess,
Macromolecules, 29, 5427 (1996)
a) Blümich, B., C. B?ffel, G. S. Harbison, Y. Yang and H. W.
Spiess:
Two-Dimensional MAS NMR: New Prospects for the Investigation of
Partially Oriented Polymers. Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 91, 1100-1103
(1987).
b) Yang, Y., M. Schuster, B. Blümich and H. W. Spiess:
Dynamic Magic-Angle Spinning NMR Spectroscopy: Exchange-Induced
Sidebands. Chem. Phys. Lett. 139, 239-243 (1987).
c) Yang, Y., A. Hagemeyer, B. Blümich and H. W. Spiess:
2D Magic Angle Spinning NMR Spectroscopy: Correlation Between
Molecular Order and Dynamics. Chem. Phys. Lett. 150, 1-5 (1988).
d) Yang, Y., A. Hagemeyer and H. W. Spiess:
Order-Exchange Correlated Two-Dimensional NMR Study of Slow
Molecular Motion in Highly Oriented Crystalline Poly(oxymethylene).
Macromolecules 22, 1004-1006 (1989).
e) Zhang, U. Wiesner, Y. Ynag, T. Pakula, and H. W. Spiess:
Annealing Effects on Orientation in Dynamically Sheared Diblock
Copolymers. Macromolecules 29, 5427-5431 (1996). P-96-107
2）Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz Prize 这个奖颁发给在德国工作的杰出科
学家，只接针对实验室主要负责人，奖金也用于实验室科研，不可能颁发给不是
PI的博士后。
3）在杨校长做博士后工作期间，Prof. Hans Wolfgang Spiess 确实获得了
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz Prize. 根据个人简历，他在去MPI之前的1981年已
经拿到教授职位，这个在德国非常不容易。而MPI总是找顶尖的教授加入其团队
并提供充足的经费。Spiess实验室从1985年起每年发表十余篇NMR方面的论文。
一切都说明Spiess教授在这个领域已经是权威人物。这个奖项是对他科研贡献的
肯定与鼓励，和谁是博士后做了什么无关。
你不吹，就上不去！有一次973答辩，答辩结束，院士很生气，说什么时候973首席比我院士的地位高了，借此大大难为了一下答辩的首席。呵呵！这个首席，我们私下都说是个水货！ 
正常